Supper Lunch

The Ultimate Cheese Toastie with Bread & Butter Pickles

The Ultimate Cheese Toastie with Bread & Butter Pickles
Nobody can resist this perfectly balanced combination of gooey cheese, crunchy toast and sharp pickles

20 minutes, plus cooling time prep, 12 minutes cook

Serves 2

Ingredients

150g aged Gruyère, finely grated

1 tbsp dry white wine

3 tbsps crème fraîche

65g butter, softened

4 slices sourdough or rustic white bread

1 tbsp Dijon mustard

2 thick slices good-quality cooked ham

A crisp green salad, to serve

For the bread & butter pickles:

200g cucumber

½ white onion

1 tbsp sea salt

150ml white wine vinegar

75g soft light brown sugar

½ tsp ground turmeric

½ tsp yellow mustard seeds

½ tsp dill seeds

A few black peppercorns

Method

To make the pickles, thickly slice the cucumber and onion into 3-mm slices, place together in a colander and sprinkle with the salt. Set the colander over a bowl and drain for 2 hours. Taste the cucumber – if it is too salty, rinse thoroughly in cold water and then drain again. Pat dry with paper towels.

Place the remaining pickle ingredients in a saucepan with 75ml water and bring to the boil, stirring to dissolve the sugar, then simmer for 10 minutes. Add the cucumber and onion and return to the boil. Immediately remove the pan from the heat and ladle the vegetables and liquid into a sterilized 1-litre jar. Seal the jar with a vinegar-safe lid and leave to cool.

To make the toasties, preheat the oven to 190°C/Fan 170°C/Gas 5. In a bowl combine the Gruyère, wine, crème fraîche and some pepper to make a paste. Spread one side of each piece of bread with butter followed by a little mustard and place 2 of the slices mustard side up on a board. Spread half of the cheese paste over the mustard and top with the ham, then the remaining cheese paste. Pop the remaining slices of bread mustard side down over the cheese layer and press firmly together.

Melt the remaining butter in a large ovenproof frying pan over a medium-low heat and, as soon as it melts, add the sandwiches and cook for 1 minute on each side until lightly golden. Transfer the pan to the preheated oven and bake for 10 minutes until all is golden, gooey and yummy. Serve with the pickles and a crisp green salad.

Great British Food Awards
HOW TO ENTER

More recipes to try

Tom Kerridge’s Grilled Goat’s Cheese Salad Recipe
Main Starter Light Bites
Tom Kerridge’s Grilled Goat’s Cheese Salad Recipe

20 minutes

Serves 2

Tom Kerridge’s Crab Cakes Recipe
Main Starter Light Bites
Tom Kerridge’s Crab Cakes Recipe

20 minutes plus 20 minutes chilling time

Serves 12

River Cottage Plum, Chocolate & Orange Lattice Tart Recipe
Pudding Supper Lunch
River Cottage Plum, Chocolate & Orange Lattice Tart Recipe

30 minutes

Serves 6-8

Macaroni Cheese, Peas & Greens
Vegetarian Supper
Macaroni Cheese, Peas & Greens

20 minutes

Serves 4-5

Garofalo Orecchiette Pasta with San Marzano Tomatoes & Burrata
Main Vegetarian Supper
Garofalo Orecchiette Pasta with San Marzano Tomatoes & Burrata

25 minutes

Serves 4

Perfect Vodka Rigatoni
Main Vegetarian Supper
Perfect Vodka Rigatoni

10 minutes

Serves 4

Venison Rogan Josh Curry
Main Supper
Venison Rogan Josh Curry

30 minutes, plus marinating time

Serves 4

Great British Food Awards
2026 AWARDS OPENING SOON
Tasting videos
3 of the best biscuit and tea pairings
3 of the best biscuit and tea pairings

Treat yourself by discovering three decadent ways to match award-winning biscuits with tea

How to cook perfect crispy bacon
How to cook perfect crispy bacon

Watch this if you're fed up with soggy bacon sandwiches